SOSL Young Soloist Concert
Tuesday, November 13th, 2007This review has been left unfinished for a while now. I usually get a review of an event out the day after I attend but due to unavoidable circumstances couldn’t find time to give this the attention it deserved before now. Thankfully time hasn’t dulled my memory of the events, so here goes…
It’s been a couple of years since I last attended a Symphony Orchestra of Sri Lanka (SOSL) and over ten years since I’ve been on stage with them (though not as part of the orchestra). I’m glad to see that there has been some improvement. Before I start I have to state that I admire this orchestra and its members for what they achieve with what little they have. The orchestra is run by donations with no government support and all the musicians are volunteers. If they do get paid I don’t imagine it could be much. That in itself is commendable.
Conducted by Ananda Dabare
Soprano: Dhanushi Wijeyakulasuriya
Violinist: Satish Casie Chetty
Composer and Guest Conductor: Eshantha J. Peiris
Pianist: Nuwan Senaratne
More information on this concert can be found at the SOSL Homepage.
I will organize this review by its participants. The orchestra (and it’s conductor) first followed by the guest conductor and his composition and end with reviews of the three soloists.
The SOSL
I’ve stated before that this orchestra does a lot with what little it has. At the same time I’d also go as far as saying that there are a few things that it shouldn’t do, mainly because it doesn’t work for them. Most of the first half of this concert worked well simply because the music chosen suited the orchestra. This is primarily due to a few small but fundamental drawbacks of the orchestra.
The first and most important is that this orchestra performs as a group of individuals all following the conductor. While Ananda Dabare does a good job it just isn’t quite enough to keep things flowing smoothly. Instead of the first violins (for example) playing in sync with each other they try to play the music alone and this really doesn’t work. The discrepancies in the bowing is very visible, they may start on time but any subsequent note is usually out of sync. However, it should be said that their pizzicato passages are usually very good, though that only accounts for less than 1% of orchestral scoring.
The brass section is as I remember them. They can be good at times, but there’s too much Marching Band still flowing in their veins. Dynamics is still something they have trouble with. Starting out loud is fine, but starting out soft and building volume is still a little challenging for them. As for the woodwinds, well… they seem to lack confidence. They tend to sound like they’re perpetually late for the party. They arrive around the right time, dither around as if unsure if they’ve arrived at the right place and then just drift around oblivious to their surroundings. There’s a feeling like they’re uncared about, which is sad because I know they can be much better.
I remember RJD saying that the only way and orchestra sounds like an orchestra is if the individual sections take time to rehearse together so that they produce an uniform sound. Only then can they be brought into the whole context of the piece being played.
Then there’s the problem of the inconsistency in the overall quality of the instruments used, but sadly there really isn’t much that can be done about that, unless the SOSL wins the lottery, of course.
Overall, I was quite pleased with the LSO’s performance on the night with a few exceptions.
Eshantha J. Peiris - Guest Conductor and Composer
I can’t recall ever seeing a date used as the title for a piece of music, but 26/12/2004 does make a lot of sense. The music itself reminded me of many things, all of which escape me at this time. This was music of the moment, more an event than an artifact. You experience it and you walk away a changed person. Musically, apart from a general feeling of Ennio Morricone this music was contemporary and Asian, two things of which I know very little so I will comment no further.
The orchestra performed admirably. I’d go so far as to say that this was their best playing of the night. If this piece is ever recorded I do hope that the LSO should have the honour of sitting in front of the mikes.
Satish Casie Chetty - Violinist
My first impression of Satish’s playing was not good. The chap looks positively Vegan, and sounded just as weak. As he walked on stage I was worried he’d fall over from the exertion. The Beethoven Romance for Violin and Orchestra No. 2 was executed fairly competently, but weakly.
The Russian Dance from Swan Lake was much more enjoyable. It was here that Satish really shone. His technique, while still delicate was accurate and well executed. While he still needs to work on his stage presence and maybe get more protein in his diet I think this fellow shows good promise and can’t wait to hear him again.
Dhanushi Wijeyakulasuriya - Soprano
I was a little worried when I first saw Dhanushi. Her programmed music suggested a much larger person, not someone as tiny as she is. The chosen music is physically and vocally demanding and her slight frame puts her at a significant disadvantage. Thankfully, this didn’t seem to worry her too much. Her singing was generally good, though she was often at the limits of her ability. While I enjoyed her performance I do think more care should be taken in choosing her repertoire in future. Someone this young and small shouldn’t be straining her voice on music this demanding. Personally I’d quite like to hear her sing some Handel or Schubert. Overall, I think the Mozart was the best of the lot.
Nuwan Senaratne
I was looking forward to this, which is why I’m so disappointed. I’d say about 90% of the blame for this lies on the piano. I’ve heard an played a lot of pianos in my time. Some were sublime, some were passable, and some were bad. This inspired in me the urge to attack it with an axe, set the shards alight and dance on the ashes. It was really that bad. It was completely muddy and there were simply no perceptible dynamics. It was like listening to a piano underwater while stoned. It could have made Michelangeli sound bad.
And then there’s the orchestra. All those things I mentioned before… the timing, the general lack of coordination, the uncertainty all came into play in this final piece. Sadly, this is one of the pieces that the SOSL isn’t quite ready to play yet and shouldn’t attempt again for a very long time.
Nuwan, was… I don’t really know if he was any good or not. My instinct tells me he played well enough, but because of how distorted his performance came across on that piano it would be unfair for me to really comment on his playing. There were wrong notes played, but whether these were mistakes or simply due to sticky keys is still a mystery to me. I could deal with it if he was good, or if he was bad… but not knowing if he was either is a rather depressing place to be.
In conclusion
Overall I was quite happy with this performance. The SOSL is still soldiering on as best it can and doing a pretty good job of it. They do occasionally aim higher than they are able to achieve, but I’ll put that down to optimism. Hopefully they’ll hit the mark someday soon and I hope I’m there to see it.
